It was addressed to me.
It offered a private settlement.
No admission of wrongdoing.
A sum of money.
In exchange, Ava would recant her statement and I would withdraw my cooperation with the investigation.
I read it at Patricia’s office.
When I finished, I set it on her desk.
“No,” I said.
Patricia picked up her pen.
“I’ll draft the response.”
“Make it short,” I said.
She almost smiled.
“I will.”
On the way home, Ava asked what the letter had said.
“He offered money to make it stop,” I told her.
She was quiet for a moment.
“What did you say?”
“No.”
She looked out the window.
After a long pause, she said: “Chloe would have said the same thing.”
I didn’t answer.
But I reached over and put my hand briefly on hers.
That was enough.
The accident reconstruction took eleven days.
I learned more about that road than I ever wanted to know — the grade of the curve, the drainage pattern, the tire marks still faintly visible in the shoulder after five years.
The original investigators had concluded driver error consistent with an inexperienced teenager in wet conditions.
The new team looked at the same road with different questions.
Patricia called on a Wednesday afternoon.
“The reconstruction is inconsistent with Daniel’s account,” she said.
“The point of impact and the vehicle’s trajectory indicate the car was traveling faster than he claimed, and the steering input in the final seconds is inconsistent with a correction.
It’s consistent with a sudden, sharp movement — the kind caused by a struggle.”
“Consistent with Chloe grabbing his arm,” I said.
“Or consistent with him pushing her, yes.
The report doesn’t assign cause — it just establishes that the physical evidence doesn’t support his version.” She paused.
“Combined with everything else, Reyes is moving forward.
Formal charges will be filed by end of week.”
I was standing in the backyard when she told me.
The garden Chloe had helped me plant the summer she was fifteen — the rose bushes along the fence, the lavender she’d insisted on even though I’d said it wouldn’t survive the winter.
It had survived every winter since.
“Ellen,” Patricia said.
“Are you there?”
“Yes,” I said.
“I’m here.”
“This is going to become public.
Once charges are filed, it will be in the local news.
People who knew Daniel, who knew your family — they’ll see it.”
